Episode 57 – To Prune or Not to Prune? Cleaning-up the Garden in Fall

Ground Breaking Banter - Rick

On this week's show, we're talking about fall clean-up and the always perplexing question of what to cut back and what not to cut back. In general, herbaceous perennials, which come back from the ground, can be cut back, whereas shrubs, which emerge on the branches that persist through winter, should not. But when in doubt, just don't prune! Besides, many people nowadays espouse a "leave the leaves" (and stems!) approach, which provides habitat, protection, and food for overwinter insects, birds, and other wildlife. Hear the whole conversation on your favorite podcast platform or at the YouTube link above.

Caryopteris is also known as bluebeard and blue mist spirea, and though it is actually a shrub with stems that are made of true wood, many people think of it as a perennial, and that leads to confusion on when – and if – it should be cut back. So on this show that’s dedicated to cutting things back and knowing the difference, I thought I’d tackle a plant that has often caused confusion.

But first, let’s paint the picture of Beyond Midnight caryopteris. With two common names that include “blue,” it’s probably not surprising that the flowers are, indeed, blue. And I’d say the overall impression of the plant is a true blue because Beyond Midnight has much darker foliage than your typical caryopteris. It’s a unique silvery-green color that makes a beautiful contrast with the purple-blue flowers. But what’s really special about Beyond Midnight, and caryopteris in general, is that it blooms in fall, bringing unexpected color and interest to the landscape. It’s also a pollinator magnet. A former colleague of mine used to call it “the bumblebee motel” because that is what it’s like – just a pulsing, buzzing mass of life in bloom. Especially since it’s super floriferous. Another feature is that after the whiskered (hence the name “bluebeard”) flowers fall, the little bract they leave behind turns a dusty blue color. It’s really an interesting transformation.

Caryopteris is best treated like butterfly bush – it has similar growing needs and grows in a similar manner. So if you have butterfly bush and have been successful with it, caryopteris is a natural addition to your garden. If you’re new to it, this is a plant that you should cut back in spring. Like butterfly bush, it can experience winter dieback in the colder ends of its range (USDA zones 5-6 – it’s hardy in zones 5-9), so is best left whole for winter, which helps to protect the buds. Some caryopteris will spread by seed, so if this is an issue, just prune off the spent flowers in fall and save any major pruning for spring.

If you’d like to add Beyond Midnight caryopteris – or any of the 320+ Proven Winners ColorChoice Shrubs – to your garden or landscape, you’ll find a list of local retailers here. 

Gardening Mail Bag - Stacey

One of the tricky things about roses of Sharon is that the flower buds and seed pods look similar to the untrained eye, so very often, what someone thinks should be a flower actually was one already. The easiest way to tell is to use your garden pruners to cut one in half. If it reveals something that looks a bit like a cross-section of okra, with a lot of round, white seeds inside, it’s a seed pod. If you’re seeing something else, it may be a flower bud that’s not opening, particularly if it’s earlier in the season than September-October. 

Roses of Sharon under extreme stress might not bloom, but in this case, the stress would also be manifesting in unhealthy looking foliage, poor growth, etc. Another possibility is something known as a hibiscus midge, a tiny fly that burrows into the developing flower bud. You can test for the presence of these in summer by placing some buds (or what you suspect are buds) in a plastic bag and putting it in a warm spot for a few days. If it is the midge, the tiny larvae will be visible in the bag. This is an unusual case for roses of Sharon, though.

The fact that this seems to coincide with recent tornado damage suggests that there is additional damage to the tree that you might not be seeing. It’s not normal for pine sap to flow very strongly at this point, so it’s probably due to injury. Another possibility is a bark beetle. There are a number of different types that can take up residence in pines, but in severe infestations, the pine will increase sap flow in an effort to unseat them from their chosen home. We recommend that you get a pair of binoculars and search the tree to find the source(s) of the sap, and look for either cracks, splits, or other breakage nearby, or the tell-tale holes and sawdust-like substance known as frass.

Hydrangeas are susceptible to a number of leaf spots, especially in years with high spring rainfall, high humidity, and in scenarios where the foliage is frequently wetted by irrigation. Though they are unsightly, they are not harmful to the overall health of the plant. It’s important to understand that fungal leaf spots are on the plant, not in the plant, so once the foliage drops in fall, the disease goes with it. However, the fungal spores do spend winter on the leaves, waiting to reinfect the plant the next spring if conditions allow. As such, we do recommend carefully removing and discarding all the foliage when it drops – this will go a long way toward minimizing leaf spot in the future, though in years where conditions are very favorable to its development, you may still see it from time to time. 

Do you have a question for us? We’re happy to help! E-mail us or use the contact tab above. Due to high volume, we may not get to your question, so if you need an answer quickly, please reach out via the Proven Winners website.

Branching News - Rick

Expand/Collapse Content
  • It’s nuts and a squirrel feast! Get ready for an Oak tree “mast year.” My neighbor’s renters are already complaining! Here in Michigan we have an Omega Block, an oak mast, a full moon and flamingos in Lake Michigan. There is something in the air.
  • The 2023 growing season in Michigan and other Midwest states has been unique and highly variable. In some places, early planting was possible in late April because soil had warmed sufficiently following a record warm third week of the month. However, the joy of early planting did not last long as a long period of drought began in April and persisted in many areas through mid-June. The drought resulted in uneven germination and stand establishment in many areas.  Adequate moisture is critical for corn germination and emergence. The seeds need to absorb about 30-35% of their weight to begin germination. Dry soils after planting in 2023 led to delayed and uneven emergence.  Drought stress during vegetative growth can reduce stem and leaf cell expansion. Severe drought stress can slow development and increase the time in vegetative stages. However, when drought is combined with heat stress, vegetative development progresses more rapidly.
  • Fall has only just begun, but it’s not too soon to look ahead to winter, especially since this one may look drastically different than recent years.
  • A 131.4-pound butternut squash was dubbed the world’s biggest at the giant veggie weigh-off at the State Fair of Virginia on Saturday.
  • It must be fall. Starbucks’ pumpkin spice latte, which turned 20 on Aug. 24, is a harbinger of fall for fanatics.  The pumpkin spice loaf has returned to Costco bakery shelves. And at one of the largest harvest festivals in the UK, there are 35 categories for giant or long vegetables, and this year 8 new world records were set, including for Largest Runner Bean Leaf, Heaviest Runner Bean, Tallest Tomatillo Plant, Longest Luffa, Heaviest Bell Pepper, Heaviest Cucumber, Heaviest Broad Bean, and Longest Broad Bean. Ian Stott brought along a 49-pound cabbage which secured him second spot on the winner’s podium this year. At last weekend’s Malvern Autumn Festival in the UK, growers from across the Isles showed off the truly frightening proportions that vegetables can grow to, headlined by massive pumpkins brought in on a forklift. At 638 kilograms, or 1,373 lbs, the gargantuan gourd was 40 kilograms more than the second-place entry, but half as heavy as the current Guinness World Record for heaviest pumpkin, which was 2,700 pounds.
  • Share:

    Episode 214 – Breaking Down Bulbs

    You can never have too many bulbs! Learn all about the numerous types of bulbs, when and how to plant them for the best success, and how to combine them with other plants for a showstopping display.

    Read More »

    Episode 213 – The Rose Family | All About Rosaceae

    The Rosaceae family includes some of the most economically important fruit and nut crops worldwide, such as apples, strawberries, and almonds. Not to mention, some extraordinarily beautiful and wildlife benefitting plants! Learn all about this vast and unique plant family in this episode.

    Read More »